I would be inclined to say,
A) For roughly 100 years, everyone with the heavenly hope was a member of the Faithful & Discreet Slave, but not anymore after the Annual Meeting. I'm confused that Jehovah allowed an apparently false teaching to persist for so long.
B) Since Christ is going to judge everyone, Scripturally it would be totally wrong for me to assume his role and say if someone is already faithful & discreet or not. Would you do such a thing?